8 subtle signs you’re more than just a friend to her (but she doesn’t want you to know it)

We sometimes include products we think are useful for our readers. If you buy through links on this page, we may earn a small commission. Read our affiliate disclosure.
8 clear-cut signs she's pining for you but doesn't want you to know it

Ever had that sneaky suspicion that she might be more into you than she lets on?

But then you find yourself second-guessing, wondering if it’s all just a figment of your imagination.

Well, let’s clear the air once and for all.

Today, I give you the female perspective and help you decode those tricky signals, so you can finally put your suspicions to rest.

Let’s dive in.

1. She contacts you out of the blue for no real reason

So, I was chatting with a friend of mine just the other day. Over a cup of coffee, we started talking about relationships and how sometimes people struggle to express their true feelings. She told me about this guy she’s been really into but doesn’t want him to know it yet.

Then she said something that struck me. “You know,” she began, “I text him all the time, but I always make sure it seems casual. Like I’m just checking in or sharing something I know he’d find interesting. But really, I just want to talk to him.”

It got me thinking. So many of us women do this when we’re really into someone. Is a girl sending you those “just because” texts or messages on social media?

If she’s reaching out to you consistently, even for seemingly no reason at all, she might be trying to keep you close without revealing how much she really cares.

2. She remembers the little things

Just the other day, I was scrolling through Instagram and stumbled across a quote that said, “People remember what’s important to them.”

And it’s so true. When we care about someone, we tend to remember the details – their favorite song, their dog’s name, that random story they told us about their trip to Italy in 2012.

Does she have a keen memory for the little things about you? Remember your mom’s birthday? The name of your childhood pet?

If she’s paying attention to all those tiny details and recalling them later, she might be telling you something without saying anything at all.

She cares about you and your life, maybe more than she’s letting on.

3. She’s “casually” curious about your future plans 

Another telltale sign that she harbors deeper feelings is her enthusiasm for your future.

It’s not just about what you’re doing next weekend, but where you envision yourself in five years, or what dreams you’re chasing. This isn’t casual chit-chat; it’s her way of subtly aligning her compass with yours.

Imagine this scenario: You’re talking about a dream job in another city, and instead of a simple nod, she dives deeper, asking how you’d feel about moving, what challenges you anticipate, or what excites you about the opportunity. 

Her questions about your future are more than curiosity; they’re a barometer of her investment in you. She’s not just in this for the fleeting moments; she’s pondering how your paths might intertwine in the chapters to come.

Keep an ear out for these conversations; they’re her heart’s way of mapping out a potential journey with you at the center.

4. She subtly creates shared rituals or traditions

Think of the little things that have become ‘yours’ over time. It could be as simple as a specific coffee shop you always visit together, or an inside joke that’s become a recurring theme in your conversations. 

These shared rituals are like unspoken agreements that silently acknowledge the special connection between you. 

Her effort in establishing these indicates that she values the connection she has with you and is actively working to nurture and grow it. It’s a sign that she cherishes the exclusivity of what you have together. It points to a deeper emotional investment in you, hinting at feelings that go beyond a casual friendship. 

5. She leans in, she touches her hair…

I recently read an article about the importance of body language in communication. It explained how our physical cues often speak louder than our words.

This got me thinking about how these non-verbal signals might play out when someone is trying to hide their feelings.

Does she lean in when you’re talking? Does she maintain eye contact more than usual? Maybe you’ve noticed her subtly touching her face or playing with her hair during conversations?

If so, there are probably unconscious actions revealing her hidden feelings. Body language can be an incredibly powerful tool in understanding what she’s trying not to say.

Pay attention to these small signs, they might just reveal more than you think.

6. She goes out of her way for you

Does she make an effort to be there for you? Does she go out of her way to do things that would make your life easier or happier?

Maybe she brings you your favorite coffee when you’re having a long day, or shows up to support you at events that are important to you.

If she’s making these extra efforts, it could be a clear-cut sign she’s into you. She’s investing time and energy into your happiness, which may indicate that she cares about you deeply, even if she’s not ready to admit it just yet.

7. She gets a little jealous

I recall a time when I felt an unexpected pang of jealousy seeing a close friend spending time with someone new. It surprised me because I hadn’t realized that I had developed feelings for him until that moment. That got me thinking about how jealousy can sometimes be a tell-tale sign of hidden feelings.

Does she show signs of being a little jealous when you are with other friends or when you talk about other women? Does she seem to be subtly competing for your attention or gets a tad too curious about your love life?

If she’s showing these signs, it could mean that she sees you as more than just a friend and is worried about losing your attention to someone else.

It’s one of the most natural human reactions and might be her heart’s way of revealing what she’s trying so hard to hide.

8. She lets her guard down 

Finally, but certainly not the least important, is how comfortable she is around you.

A friend recently told me about a guy she’s been falling for. She said, “I can be my true self around him, no pretenses.” That got me thinking about how comfort and authenticity often go hand-in-hand with deep affection.

So, does she let her guard down when you’re together? Is she comfortable sharing her thoughts, her worries, her silly side, and maybe even her insecurities? Does she trust you enough to be vulnerable?

If she’s that open with you, it’s a pretty solid sign that she holds you in high regard. She might be feeling more for you than what meets the eye. Her comfort around you could very well be a sign of hidden affection and trust.

The bottom line

The heart has its ways of revealing itself, even when we try to hide it.

So, keep your eyes open, your mind understanding, and your heart ready. She might be telling you more than she says.